Review of Syfy’s Alice
There are a couple of other posts summarizing the two part Alice series on Syfy, but I ended up saving most of my real opinions for this post.
My Real Opinion
To me, it seems like the writers at Syfy simply combined plots from several different science fiction, action and adventure movies, and then just named all of the characters after the ones from Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass. There is essentially none of the playfulness or innocence of the original books or movies in Syfy’s version. Even American McGee’s Alice, which was extremely dark, still felt a bit innocent and playful in it’s own way. Maybe they got caught up trying to make it into a science fiction series, and then got lost when they tried to incorporate Wonderland into the plot.
The Matrix
One movie that Syfy’s Alice seems similar to is the Matrix. Almost all of the Queen’s henchmen look like agents from the Matrix — men in black suits wielding shotguns. The only henchmen who don’t look like agents from the Matrix are those who are supposed to be characters from Alice in Wonderland such as the March Hare, Tweedle Dee, Tweedle Dum, and the stupid looking guard with a club shaped headpiece. Even the March Hare, the coolest looking character, looks like an agent with a rabbit’s head. Also, Wonderland looks like a rundown metropolitan area, which is very Matrix-like.
Ring of Wonderland?
The next thing that I didn’t like about Syfy’s Alice was that they tried to incorporate the Ring of Wonderland into the series. Its possible that they got the idea from Lord of the Rings, but one thing is for sure — there isn’t a ring in any other previous versions of Alice in Wonderland. Perhaps they wanted a way for Alice to travel into Wonderland without dream sequences and drug references, or perhaps they were just trying to sell jewelry since Kay Jewelers sponsored the series. Either way, the ring is kind of lame as a plot device. I do respect the fact that they were trying a new angle on the story, but I just don’t think that it worked out very well.
Visual Appeal
The third thing that I didn’t like about the series was that it wasn’t very visually appealing. Yes, it was a low budget action series on a cable channel, but why even bother making a series about Wonderland if its not going to look amazing? Parts of the set, like the casino, looked pretty cool but overall the scenes looked drab and under decorated.
In conclusion, Alice in Wonderland was better when it was a brightly colored story about trippy talking cats, grumpy smoking caterpillars, and mad tea parties. The plot line about the ring, the agents from the Matrix, and the twenty-something version of Alice who has father issues was too far off base for me to enjoy personally. On the other hand, if they hadn’t associated the series with Alice in Wonderland, then I wouldn’t have watched it, so I guess they did what they had to do to get viewers.
December 12th 2009 in Reviews









